Alarming! Politicians are as obsessed with the urban dream as the rest of us!
I was researching an article about the governance of privately built cities recently and one of the experts I spoke to commented on the obsession of the Indian State with being answerable to the urban middle class, to the exclusion of other categories of citizens like the rural folk, the urban poor etc who have traditionally been the ‘vote bank’ in India. After Ayona seeded that thought in my head, I began to notice that it was indeed being pointed out by several journalists and experts in mainstream media. For instance, this piece talks about Modi’s obsession with the urban. It’s not just Modi, our nation is seeing a disturbing shift in which the youth aspire to everything that is urban. Symbolism is important and cars, mobile phones, branded clothes and a ‘liberal’ lifestyle have become outward signs of a change in outlook (not mindsets though, as we are reminded time and again!).
Sanjoy Narayan’s editorial in Hindustan Times this weekend describes how painfully aware young people are of the stark inequalities. I imagined, as I read, this sea of young people gravitating towards a lifestyle they couldn’t sustain, leaving behind a familiar life that they look down on.
At the India Art Fair, a panel of photographs from the South Indian countryside of homes that mimic urban architecture paints a clear picture of how the city is a major part of the dreams of people across the country.
As an architect and urbanist, I clearly see how people with “one foot in the city and one foot in the village” (am borrowing these words from Rahul Srivastava of URBZ), carry back home the symbols of their city life, recreating in villages and small towns across the country the palatial urban-style homes of their dreams that the city doesn’t give them space for! Often times, no one lives in these countryside palaces!
Mohan, a passionate and inspiring young man I know quite well, built such a home back in Odisha while he made money running a grocery store in Gurgaon. His aging parents lived in this large home by themselves for many years. Mohan’s frustration with the anomaly of the situation has been growing for a year or so and he recently made the brave decision of moving back to start a business in a small town near his home. I sincerely wish him well. His brothers refuse to move away and they are absolutely certain Mohan will fail and the relatively big bucks in the big city will bring him right back (his tail between his legs!).
Everyone, politicians and bureaucrats as well as educated people regardless of caste and class, have fallen for the urban dream hook, line and sinker. The few who, like Mohan, dare to dream different are laughed at. We’ve bought our own bullshit, literally. We believe that an industrialized future is the way forward. We prefer not to think about how the food will get to our table, where wild animals will live, where we will go when we want to escape the city, where our water tables will get recharged….. it’s too painful to think about, we hope that there are rules to sort that stuff out!
The truth is that most of us are entitled to live in our own imagined worlds or urban prosperity. It alarms me, however, when politicians do the same. That those in power and those in line for power propagate this imbalanced situation as a dream we must dream, it’s worrying indeed! Cashing in on the urban aspirations of rural folk, politicians are shamelessly painting a false picture. They are showing us dreams that will never be fulfilled and that will push us further into environmental disaster, food insecurity and sharpened inequalities.
Sobering thought, if you needed another one- To be able to vote in people who see the whole picture at some point in the future, we would need to see the whole picture for ourselves.
Posted on February 10, 2014, in Politics & Citizenship and tagged ambition, aspiration, housing, migration, politician, rural, urban, urban dream, urban rural divide. Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.
Absolutely brilliant post Mukta. Spot on. Everyone is dreaming about living in cities and making big bucks. But we don’t realise that buck stops here. As I live in Kerala, we have seen many peopl e going out of Kerala and settling down in Bangalore, Chennai or the Middle East. When I talk to young people over here, they want to be like their neighbourhood bhaiyya who lives a posh life in far away city! (Although he is a driver in that city)
But few people realise the importance of being in their home town, work for their motherland and nurture the talents here. This is one of the ill effects of globalization!
Just read this – I also stood in front of that photo panel at the Art Fair. I was reminded again of it as I drove home from the airport in Goa last week!
We are at the cross roads – in almost everything. And, we have through our poor investment in education over the last few decades, few participants in public discourse and poor quality of the discourse. And politicians are part of this eco-system… its going to be a long and ardous task to change this. But change it will…..
yes, i see hope as well!
When you look at such phenomena you should also look at the sociological side. UP/Bihar people loving Maharashtra because of equality, dignity and a higher quotient of dignity of labour. Flip side is my relatives in Pune vote MNS against North Indians destroying Pune. My Masi now claims she is Maharashtrian.
Reblogged this on Jugraphia Slate.